Welcome to H3 Maths

Blog Support for Growing Mathematicians

Probabilities and Courtroom Drama


In 1964 a Los Angeles blond woman with a ponytail snatched a purse from another woman. The thief was spotted entering a yellow car driven by a black man with a beard and a mustache. The police eventually found a blond woman with a ponytail who regularly associated with a bearded and mustachioed black man who owned a yellow car, but there was no hard evidence linking them to the crime. In court, the prosecutor argued that the probability was so low that such a couple existed that the police must have found the actual culprits. The prosecutor assigned the following probabilities to the characteristics in question:

yellow car: 1 in 10 or 1/10
man with a mustache: 1/4
woman with ponytail: 1/10
woman with blond hair: 1/3
black man with beard: 1/10
interracial couple in a car: 1/1000

The prosecutor argued that the characteristics were independent, so the probability that a randomly selected couple would have them all would be:

(1 x 10) x (1 x 4) x (1 x 10) x (1 x 3) x (1 x 10) x (1 x 1000) = 1 in 12,000,000

This, he argued, was a probability so low that the couple must be guilty. The jury agreed and convicted them.” (extract from: Innumeracy-Mathematical Illiteracy and its Consequences)
BUT, the case was appealed to the California Supreme Court. What do you think the outcome was? (more in another post soon)

by posted under Uncategorized | Comments Off on Probabilities and Courtroom Drama    

Comments are closed.

Post Support

The graph on the left (Coronavirus) is for a time period of 30 days, while the one on the right (SARS) is for 8 months! Very poor graphical comparison and hardly relevant, unless it is attempting to downplay the seriousness of the coronavirus?

10 x 9 x 8 + (7 + 6) x 5 x 4 x (3 + 2) x 1 = 2020

NCEA Level 2 Algebra Problem. Using the information given, the shaded area = 9, that is:
y(y-8) = 9 –> y.y – 8y – 9 =0
–> (y-9)(y+1) = 0, therefore y = 9 (can’t have a distance of – 1 for the other solution for y)
Using the top and bottom of the rectangle,
x = (y-8)(y+2) = (9-8)(9+2) = 11
but, the left side = (x-4) = 11-4 = 7, but rhs = y+? = 9+?, which is greater than the value of the opp. side??
[I think that the left had side was a mistake and should have read (x+4)?]

H3 Viewers

Skip to toolbar